← all essays
Economics· 5 min read

Why 85% of your fraud checks should cost you nothing

Validation became a commodity — open lists, free DNS, public registries made the easy answers free. The vendors billing you for every check are selling yesterday’s scarcity.

Something strange happened to data validation while everyone was watching the AI boom: the easy answers became free. Open-source blocklists now track well over 160,000 disposable email domains. Every mail domain’s existence is a free DNS query away. Phone-number structure is a solved, offline problem. IP provenance has open databases and generous free tiers.

Which raises an uncomfortable question for anyone paying per-check pricing: what exactly are you paying for?

The dirty secret of per-check pricing

Legacy validators bill you for every lookup — including the ones that were obvious before any network call. A syntax-mangled email. A domain from a known temp-mail service. A phone number with a reserved fictional prefix. These answers cost the vendor nothing; they cost you $0.004–$0.01 each.

At 100,000 checks a month that is roughly $600 — and most of it bought verdicts a rules engine settles in microseconds. You are not paying for accuracy. You are paying for someone else’s architecture.

The cheapest fraud check is the one that never has to ask anyone.

The cascade

The alternative is a cascade that asks the cheapest question first. Step one is a local signal engine — syntax and structure, pattern and entropy analysis, blocklists built from years of abuse data. Step two is free public infrastructure — DNS deliverability checks, open registries, geolocation that costs nothing at our volumes. Only the residue — the genuinely uncertain inputs — escalates to commercial data partners who can confirm them.

In practice, about 85% of traffic is settled by the first two steps. The residue is what a credit pays for. Not the queue — the residue.

What that does to the math

Same 100,000 checks. Two invoices:

  • Legacy per-check validation: ~$600/month — every lookup billed, most of it for obvious answers
  • Cascade pricing: ~$120/month — credits spent only on the ~15% that needed external confirmation
  • The difference isn’t a discount. It’s the business model. That margin is why a free tier can exist, why bulk audits can be given away, and why pricing can stay honest while competitors ration credits.

Free is the wedge. Confidence is the product.

Nobody should pay to be told `test@tempmail.com` is fake. What is worth paying for is the confidence score on the hard 15% — the verdict you can route a checkout, a trial, a lead on, with the named signals to explain it to your CFO.

Validation commoditised. Judgement did not. We charge for the second one.